Enhancing Hiring Manager Satisfaction: The Key to Successful Recruitment

Table of Contents

“People don’t leave the companies, they leave the managers”

The level of hiring manager satisfaction is a key factor in the hiring process. The hiring managers are the ones who finally choose which applicants will be recruited and who will collaborate closely with them when they are. A great hiring process should make sure that hiring managers are actively involved in the selection and filtering of candidates while also attempting to supply them with a variety of high-quality candidates.

Hiring managers are in charge of finding, attracting, and choosing the best talent for their organizations, and they play a critical part in the recruitment process. For the hiring process to be successful and efficient, hiring managers’ satisfaction must be guaranteed. Hiring managers that are happy with their jobs are more likely to be proactive, involved, and effective in their recruitment efforts. In addition to offering ideas to improve their experience during the hiring process, this article discusses the significance of assessing and enhancing hiring manager satisfaction.

What does a hiring manager do?

A hiring manager is a company official in charge of selecting candidates to fill unfilled positions. The person who serves as the future employee’s immediate superior is typically someone from the department where the individual needs to be employed.

The hiring of new personnel is managed by hiring managers, who collaborate with recruiters and HR managers. Their main objective is to make sure the best candidate is chosen and employed, taking into account all of their qualifications and personal traits.

Key responsibilities of the hiring manager

The recruiting process involves several important steps that hiring managers must follow to  recruit and onboard new employees. Let’s take a closer look at each of these steps.  

#1 Determine the number of staff required

Before starting the recruitment process, hiring managers must assess the staffing needs of the department or organization. This includes assessing workloads, considering growth plans and identifying  positions that need to be filled due to employee turnover or expansion. 

#2 Obtaining approval to initiate a job application

Once the need for a new employee is identified, hiring managers typically must seek approval from department heads or senior management. This ensures that the hiring decision is consistent with the organization’s goals and budget. 

#3 Preparation for the hiring process

Hiring managers must take the time to prepare for the hiring process by defining the job requirements, the desired qualifications and the skills required for the position. This includes determining the key responsibilities and tasks that the new employee will be responsible for. 

#4 Write an attractive job description

To attract the best candidates, it is important to write a job description that accurately reflects the position and its requirements. The description must be both truthful and convincing and highlight the specifics of the role and the organization to pique the interest of potential candidates. 

#5 Defining the roles and responsibilities of the recruiting team

In larger organizations, recruiting is often a team effort. Hiring managers must define the roles and responsibilities of hiring team members, including recruiters, interviewers and other stakeholders. Clear expectations should be set for each team member’s participation in the interview process. 

#6 Jobs and screening resumes

Hiring managers should post the job  on relevant platforms such as job boards, company websites or social media. They must then review and screen incoming resumes to identify qualified candidates who meet the job requirements. 

#7 Conducting Interviews and Assessments

Once potential candidates have been identified, hiring managers must schedule and conduct interviews to assess their qualifications and suitability for the position. This may involve multiple rounds of interviews, skill assessments, or behavioral assessments to gauge  candidates’ skills and fit with the organization’s culture.

#8 Making the final hiring decision

After  the interview and evaluation process, hiring managers are responsible for making the final hiring decision. This decision  usually requires management approval or review to ensure that it is consistent with the  overall goals and policies of the organization. 

#9 Job offer extension

If a candidate is selected for a position, the hiring manager is responsible for extending the job offer. This includes communicating the terms of employment, such as salary, benefits and start date, and answering any questions or concerns the applicant may have. During the hiring process, hiring managers must effectively lead the recruiting team, ensure compliance with hiring practices and legal requirements, and provide a positive candidate. By following these steps, hiring managers can successfully identify, attract and retain the right talent for their organization.

Surveys during various stages on hiring manager satisfaction 

When measuring director of photography satisfaction, questionnaires are often used to assess different stages of employment.

Let’s explore these steps in more detail: 

#1 Onboarding

In this phase of the hiring manager satisfaction survey, you ask hiring managers to rate various aspects of the hiring process. This includes estimating the time it takes to start recruiting  and how quickly a job description or application can be submitted. By gathering feedback on these factors, you can identify potential delays or inefficiencies early in the recruitment process. 

Sample questions to get you started: 

  • On a scale of 1-10, how satisfied are you with the initial speed of the recruitment process? 
  • Did you receive a job description or job application on time? 
  • Were there any challenges or obstacles when you started recruiting?

#2 Lead generation

This phase focuses on evaluating the quantity and quality of the lead generation process. You can use this section of the hiring manager satisfaction survey to gather feedback on specific programs or initiatives (such as a candidate program) that you have implemented to attract potential candidates. This feedback will help you understand the effectiveness of these programs and make  necessary improvements. 

Example questions to create a candidate stage:  

  • How satisfied are you with the number of applicants for this position? 
  • How satisfied are you with the quality of  candidates who applied for this position?
  • Have you found that specific programs or initiatives have helped attract applicants? 

#3 Overall satisfaction

In this step, you ask hiring managers to rate their overall satisfaction with the hiring process as a whole. This gives them the opportunity  to provide feedback on the entire experience and highlight  areas for improvement. Additionally, you can ask them to rate the quality of hire, which reflects their satisfaction with the candidates who are ultimately selected and hired. 

Example questions for the general satisfaction stage: 

  • On a scale of 1-10, how satisfied are you with the hiring process overall? 
  • How would you rate the quality of recruitment for the recruiting positions? 
  • Do you have other suggestions to improve our promotional programs?  
  • By measuring hiring manager satisfaction at these stages, you can gain valuable insight into the strengths and weaknesses of your hiring process. 

With this feedback, you can identify areas for improvement, refine your strategies, and ensure that the employee experience meets the hiring managers’ expectations.

Why is it important to measure Hiring Manager Satisfaction?

It’s critical to gauge hiring managers’ satisfaction for a number of reasons. It results in better hiring outcomes, insightful criticism for improvement, avoiding expensive errors, resource optimisation, enhanced subsequent hiring procedures, and increases general employee happiness. Organizations may improve the hiring process, attract and retain top talent in a competitive job market by putting a high priority on hiring manager satisfaction.

#1 Happy managers = better hiring and better candidate experience

Because satisfied managers are more likely to be engaged and motivated during the recruitment process, measuring hiring manager satisfaction is essential. They are more likely to actively participate, work with recruiters, and offer insightful commentary. This involvement translates into a hiring process that is more effective and efficient, improving the candidate experience and increasing the likelihood of luring and securing top talent.

#2 Valuable feedback for the HR and recruiting teams

For HR and recruiting teams, feedback or surveys on hiring manager satisfaction offer insightful information. It is possible to pinpoint opportunities for improvement in the recruitment process by understanding the viewpoints, difficulties, and recommendations of the hiring managers. As a result of this input, sourcing tactics, interviewing procedures, or communication strategies may be modified, thereby improving the overall recruitment process for both hiring managers and candidates.

#3 Avoid bad hires or repeating mistakes

Unhappy recruiting managers may hasten the hiring process, resulting in subpar hiring choices or a higher chance of continuously making the same errors. By measuring employee happiness, businesses may spot possible problems early on, address their concerns, offer the support they need, and reduce the likelihood of making poor recruits. Organizations may raise the caliber of hires and lower turnover by making sure hiring managers are happy.

#4 Save on costs and resources 

A lot of money is spent on recruiting, vetting candidates, conducting interviews, and onboarding new hires. The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) performed data that indicates that the average cost-per-hire in the US is close to $4,000. Organizations may streamline their hiring procedures, cut down on the amount of time it takes to fill vacancies, and lessen costly mistakes by assessing hiring manager satisfaction. Cost reductions and effective resource allocation result from this.

#5 Improve future hiring 

Organizations can pinpoint areas where the hiring process needs to be improved by measuring hiring manager satisfaction. Hiring managers’ feedback may draw attention to issues like ambiguous job descriptions, poor interview questions, protracted timelines, or inadequate candidate screening procedures. Organizations can improve future hiring efforts, streamline procedures, and guarantee alignment between position specifications and candidate selection by addressing these concerns.

#6 Enhanced productivity of hiring managers  

All employees, including recruiting managers, must have their needs and expectations met for a workplace to be considered positive. Hiring managers that are content with their jobs are more likely to make positive contributions to the company, show better levels of engagement, and feel more invested in the hiring procedure. Maintaining a healthy workplace environment and developing a culture of collaboration and achievement are goals that are consistent with placing a priority on hiring manager satisfaction.

Measuring Hiring Manager Satisfaction

The most popular and extensively utilized method for gauging recruiting manager satisfaction is a survey. They offer a methodical and scalable way to get recruiting managers’ opinions about their involvement in the hiring process. Surveys are made to gather both quantitative and qualitative information, giving organizations a thorough insight of the opinions and satisfaction levels of hiring managers.

Organizations must first create a carefully thought-out survey that covers all facets of the hiring process. This contains inquiries that gauge hiring managers’ opinions of various procedures, such as the job request, candidate assessment, communication, and onboarding. The use of rating scales to collect quantitative data must be balanced with the inclusion of open-ended questions to gain qualitative feedback.

Steps in creating a hiring manager satisfaction survey

#1 Set the parameters to be measured

Cost per hire, quality of hire, areas of improvement, quality of recruitment pool etc.

#2 Make a list of questions to evaluate the below criteria 

#1 Candidate Quality

  • How satisfied are you with the quality of the candidates provided?
  • How satisfied are you with the diversity of the candidate pool?

#2 Recruitment Strategy

  • How satisfied are you with the accuracy of the job posting?
  • How satisfied are you with the number of applications/resumes received?
  • How satisfied are you with the recruitment and sourcing strategies used by HR?
  • How satisfied are you with the screening and selection process?
  • How satisfied are you with the structure of the interview procedure?

#3 Hiring process

  • How satisfied are you with the accuracy of the job description and the documentation of the required skills and work experience?
  • How satisfied are you with the speed of the hiring process?

#3 Share the survey

Decide upon the various touchpoints in the hiring process to conduct the surveys and obtain results 

#4 Reflect on the results

Review and analyze the responses to understand the various aspects, including the current highlights and shortcomings of the hiring process. 

#5 Solutioning 

Collaborate & brainstorm with hiring managers for viable solutions to address the challenges faced and tracking the results of the changes made. 

How to Improve Hiring Manager Satisfaction

#1 Connect directly to understand specific needs 

To ensure hiring manager satisfaction, it is essential to establish direct communication and understand their specific requirements. This involves gaining a clear understanding of the role they are hiring for, the desired skill set, personality traits, and cultural fit they are seeking in candidates. By actively listening to their needs and preferences, you can align your recruitment efforts to find candidates that best match their expectations. Additionally, it is crucial to discuss and understand the goals of the hiring process. By aligning your strategies with their objectives, you can create a more collaborative and effective hiring experience.

#2 Try different methods and tools based on discussion

Engaging in discussions with hiring managers can provide valuable insights into their preferences for different recruitment methods and tools. For example, you can explore writing job descriptions (JDs) differently to ensure they accurately reflect the requirements and appeal to the desired candidates. Additionally, based on the discussions, you can leverage different platforms like social media to reach a wider pool of candidates. Experimenting with various sourcing channels and techniques, such as job boards, professional networks, and referrals, can help you identify the most effective methods for attracting qualified candidates. Once you find strategies that work best, stick to them while remaining open to adapting and refining as needed.

#3 Leverage data

Data plays a crucial role in enhancing hiring manager satisfaction. By recording and analyzing hiring metrics, such as time-to-fill, candidate quality, and source effectiveness, you can identify areas of improvement and address any shortcomings. This data-driven approach allows you to understand the pain points in the hiring process and take proactive steps to overcome them. Moreover, providing hiring managers with all relevant data upfront, such as candidate profiles, assessment results, and market insights, sets clear expectations and empowers them to make informed decisions. Sharing relevant data promotes transparency, enhances collaboration, and builds trust between recruiters and hiring managers.

#4 Use the right recruitment tool

The hiring process can be greatly improved for both hiring managers and recruiters by using the appropriate recruitment technology. Hyreo and other intelligent recruitment solutions provide a number of benefits through automation, workflows, and candidate management features.

Automation is one of the main benefits of a smart recruitment tool. These technologies automate time-consuming procedures like candidate follow-up, arranging interviews, and screening resumes. Recruiters and hiring managers may focus on more strategic and valuable tasks by automating these processes, which can save them a lot of time and effort.

Workflows are yet another beneficial aspect that intelligent recruitment tools provide. With the help of these technologies, organizations can create processes that are specifically tailored to their hiring procedures. The hiring process is streamlined and standardized via workflows, assuring consistency and efficiency. They also facilitate collaboration among hiring managers and recruiters, allowing for seamless communication and information sharing.


In conclusion, measuring executive satisfaction is critical for organizations looking to optimize their hiring processes and attract top talent. Surveys are a widely used tool to gather feedback and gauge employee satisfaction from managers. They provide a structured and scalable approach that allows organizations to collect both quantitative and qualitative data for analysis. 

Surveys give organizations the opportunity to gain valuable insight into executive hiring  experiences, challenges and suggestions for improvement. By understanding their perspective, organizations can make informed decisions, improve their recruitment strategies and streamline the overall recruitment process.  The importance of employee manager satisfaction measurement cannot be overstated. This leads to better recruitment results, better candidate experiences and saves costs and resources. In addition, it provides valuable feedback to HR and recruiting teams, helps prevent bad hires or repeat mistakes, and increases the overall happiness and satisfaction of both  managers and employees. 

By prioritizing and measuring hiring manager satisfaction, organizations can create a positive hiring experience, attract top talent, and build a strong and successful workforce.

FAQs on Hiring Manager Satisfaction 

What is hiring manager satisfaction, and why is it important?

Hiring manager satisfaction refers to the level of contentment and fulfillment experienced by hiring managers throughout the recruitment process. It is important because satisfied hiring managers are more likely to be engaged, proactive, and effective in their recruitment efforts, leading to better hiring outcomes and a positive candidate experience.

How does hiring manager satisfaction impact the overall recruitment process?

Hiring manager satisfaction directly affects the quality of the recruitment process. Satisfied hiring managers are more likely to actively participate in the selection and filtering of candidates, provide valuable feedback, and collaborate effectively with recruiters and HR managers. This involvement improves the overall efficiency, effectiveness, and success of the recruitment process.

What are the key factors that contribute to hiring manager satisfaction?

Several factors contribute to hiring manager satisfaction, including clear communication and expectations, timely delivery of job requisitions, access to high-quality candidates, efficient screening and selection processes, and support from HR and recruiting teams. Additionally, a positive work environment, opportunities for growth, and alignment of organizational goals with hiring objectives also play a significant role.

Talk to an expert

Tell us what you are looking for and we'll get back to you in a jiffy!

Thank you, your feedback is valuable!